Many breastfeeding mothers are under the impression that it is necessary to own or use a pump to breastfeed. This is not so. You do not need a breast pump to breastfeed. This false notion was given emphasis in the USA, by a federal programme to provide free pumps to new mothers. It is our belief that this was a wrong path to take. Instead of pumps, what new mothers need is guaranteed, paid maternity leave, for a minimum of at least 7 months, though longer would be better still.
Too often mothers want to express breast milk so that the father can feed the baby a bottle. This notion is very much pushed by formula companies in their marketing. Ask yourself why. There are many things the father can do to help you besides giving the baby a bottle. Even if it is your own expressed breast milk in the bottle, even one bottle a day can lead to a baby starting to feed less well at the breast and the increasing “need” to give more bottles.
Mothers are also being encouraged to pump their milk and give it to baby by bottle for the most unnecessary reasons: weddings, doctor’s appointments, shopping and the list goes on. Why not take the baby with you? How can babies not be welcome at weddings? What could be a more natural place for a baby to be than a joyous family gathering? Your baby is part of the family. One of the odd things about Western society is exclusion of children from “adult” society. Then we wonder why they don’t want to have anything to do with us when they are teenagers. If it is truly necessary to leave the baby with someone else, why not use a cup (see the information sheet “Finger and Cup Feeding”)?
If you go out, take your baby with you. All states and provinces have laws or human rights codes that allow a mother to breastfeed in any location she is legally allowed to be. Strike a blow for breastfeeding mothers and babies! Breastfeed your baby in public! Your feeling of discomfort will soon be replaced by an incredible feeling of freedom. Furthermore, you will be encouraging other mothers to do the same while at the same time educating others, especially young children who may never have seen a baby at the breast before. Don’t worry, they won’t be traumatized psychologically. If you are shy about breastfeeding in public, a good place to start breastfeeding in public is at a cinema. The lights go down, the baby gets breastfeeding, is quiet, and nobody can see. Now you have done it. Next step on a bench in a virtually empty park?
We are not keen on pumping when the mother is already supplementing her breastfeeding with formula. Yes, the baby may get a little less breastmilk and take more formula but here is why we feel this way:
Pumping is expensive (to rent or buy the machine).
Pumping time consuming and can be tiring.
Pumping diminishes the mother’s enjoyment of breastfeeding.
Pumping, if not done properly, may cause sore nipples.
In spite of everything we tell mothers, that you cannot tell how much you are producing or can produce, mothers look at what they pump and may get discouraged.
Breast compression is like pumping, but instead of pumping into a bottle, you express into the baby. It works even better, in our opinion. The link http://ibconline.ca/breastcompression/, contains several videos showing breast compression increasing the baby’s intake of breastmilk.
There are a very few circumstances when it is necessary to express your milk. Certainly, if baby is not yet latching onto the breast then mother needs to express her milk in order to maintain her milk supply (see our blog Not Latching On).
Mothers may have to express/pump when the baby is very premature and not yet ready to go the breast. By the way, unlike what goes on in North America, in Scandinavia, very premature babies have been shown to be able to breastfeed and to be latching on and drinking at the breast by 30 weeks gestation. Some premature babies will be breastfeeding exclusively by 32 or 33 weeks gestation, even before they are even “allowed” to go to the breast in most North American special care units (yes, breastfeeding at the breast, not being fed breastmilk by bottle). See the information sheet on Breastfeeding the Premature Baby.
Finally, if you don’t have adequate maternity leave you may need to express your milk and in this situation we recommend you express your milk. Daycare centres are where infections pass easily from child to child. Your breastmilk will help protect your child against these infections.
Incidentally, anything less that 6 months maternity leave is inadequate. See the information sheet What to Feed the Baby When the Mother Works Outside the Home. This information sheet is geared, however, to those mothers who do have at least 6 months maternity leave. If, in your country, you have less than 6 months maternity leave, when you start having a little free time 😊, start lobbying government to do something about such a disgraceful situation.
Breastfeeding is so much more than breastmilk and whenever possible, the baby should be at the breast. A pump is not as efficient as a well-latched baby and so a baby who breastfeeds well is the “best pump”. Of course some babies don’t breastfeed well but if that is your situation, get good “hands on” help.
Many women find that hand expression is an efficient way to express milk especially when only occasional expression is required. In fact, during the first few days after birth and the milk production is not yet abundant (as is normal in the first few days), it is often easier to get milk with hand expression than with a pump and many women find this the easiest way to express mature milk as well.
Pump immediately after the feed–waiting an hour or so decreases the likelihood the breast will be full as possible for the next feed.
Remember, pumping should not hurt. If it hurts:
Unlike formula, breast milk is anti-infective, antibacterial, antifungal, and antiviral.
Breastmilk will stay good:
Some issues around expressed breastmilk:
The milk ejection reflex or “let down” reflex is a sudden release of the milk from the breast. Milk may flow quickly even if the baby is not breastfeeding at the time. Sometimes a mother may have a milk ejection just hearing the baby move around or utter baby sounds, or begin to cry. The mother may feel thirsty, sweaty, sleepy, or dizzy during a milk ejection reflex but this is unusual. However, many women do not feel this milk ejection response ever in their whole breastfeeding experience even though everything is going beautifully with breastfeeding. You do not need to feel or be aware of the milk ejection reflex in order for the baby to be getting milk (see the video clips to see if the baby is getting milk well or not). Some women only become aware of it after the first few weeks while others feel it only at the beginning and no longer do after the first few weeks. This has absolutely no bearing on milk supply.
If your baby is not present, you can encourage the milk ejection reflex artificially by thinking about having your baby in your arms or at your breast or having a picture of your baby to look at or keeping a piece of his clothing next to you.
1. Wash your hands
2. Apply a warm wet cloth to your breasts.
3. Massage the breasts in small circular motions around the perimeter of the breast.
4. Gently stroke your breasts with your fingers in a downward motion toward the nipple
5. Lean forward and gently shake the breasts.
6. Gently roll the nipple between your finger and thumb.
You may feel the milk ejection reflex or notice your breasts leaking or you may not. You are likely to express/pump more milk faster if you pump both breasts at the same time.
Breast compressions, while pumping, can be very effective at increasing the amount expressed. It may be a bit awkward at first, but it can be done (mothers have fixed the cups so that they sit inside the bra and then use compressions) or the partner can do it.
The information presented here is general and not a substitute for personalized treatment from an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC) or other qualified medical professionals.
This information sheet may be copied and distributed without further permission on the condition that it is not used in any context that violates the WHO International Code on the Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes (1981) and subsequent World Health Assembly resolutions. If you don’t know what this means, please email us to ask!
©IBC, updated July 2009, 2021
Questions or concerns? Email Dr. Jack Newman (read the page carefully, and answer the listed questions).